Written by Katya Firyan, co-founder of Writitude

The search for an expert copywriter can be sometimes a daunting task. But fear not. This guide will hand-deliver you methods that separate prolific wordsmiths from ordinary typists.

Great valuable content's the primary driver for inbound marketing, enhancing your brand presence, boosting SEO rankings and luring in potential customers.

Well-executed copy aids in clear messaging, differentiating you in the saturated market and fostering loyal customer relationships.

Simply put, effective copywriting is not a nicety, it's absolutely essential for expanding your customer base and bolstering business growth.

Identifying Your Copywriting Needs: The First Step to Finding the Perfect Copywriter

First, let’s see how to tailor your choice to specific necessities, and set a reasonable expense framework.

Understanding the Role of a Copywriter in Your Business

A copywriter is not just a word wiz. Copywriters bring value to a business by driving engagement, bolstering brand identity, and influencing consumer behaviour.

They have mastered the art of transforming complex ideas into digestible, attention-grabbing content.

Thus, acknowledging the role of a copywriter in a business goes beyond drafting words — it means understanding their potential as brand accelerators and conversion drivers.

Taking time to consider how a copywriter can fulfil your specific business objectives paves the path to pinpointing the perfect professional. Are you aiming for a boost in web traffic or an enchanting brand story?

Or perhaps you need robust SEO infused content?

Recognising the particular role a copywriter will play in your organisation is the crucial start line of your selection journey.

Determining the Type of Copywriting Services You Need

Step into the shoes of precision — identify the exact copywriting services your business needs. From technical and SEO copywriting to creative and social media copywriting — each type serves a unique purpose and contributes to different aspects of your business.

Determining the precise type of copywriting services you need can narrow down the expansive field of potentials and pave the way for a spot-on hire.

Screenshot 2024-08-04 at 15.17.24.png Chart by the Knowledge Academy

The different types of copywriting: SEO, sales, content, technical, etc.

Copywriting is a broad field with multiple specialties, each with unique demands and nuances.

SEO Copywriting SEO or Search Engine Optimisation copywriting incorporates the use of keywords and phrases strategically to improve website's rankings on search engines. It requires in-depth knowledge of SEO tactics and the art of incorporating keywords seamlessly into appealing content.

Sales Copywriting The motive of sales copywriting is to persuade the reader to buy a product or service. It involves creating persuasive sales emails, ads, sales pages, or direct mailings.

Content Copywriting Content copywriting leans more towards delivering value than directly selling. It includes educational materials and articles aimed at engaging customers and fostering brand visibility and trust.

Technical Copywriting For technical subjects like software or manufacturing processes, technical copywriting comes into play. It involves creating guides, manuals, and documents that explain complex topics in a manner that's easy to digest for the target audience.

When looking into the types of copywriting services on offer, it's worth investing some time into researching the unique traits of each. Are you an e-commerce business that could use some product description magic? Maybe your brand voice needs some sprucing up through creative copywriting?

Establishing what you want from your copywriter can help them deliver content that's not just meticulously crafted, but also finely tuned to your business objectives.

It would be preferable to include the topics and text formats you would like your writers to work with in your job advertisement. This will encourage writers with the relevant experience.

Understanding the Typical Rates for Copywriting Services

What’s reasonable to expect to pay for a top-notch copywriter?

While rates can vary based on experience, industry, and project length, you'll often find that all sterling copywriters have a certain standard price tag.

Akin to finalizing the budget for any business service, being acquainted with the current market rates beforehand can avoid any surprises or setbacks later.

Research reports suggest that the average hourly rate for a copywriter falls between $50 to $100. Yet several factors could impact this, including copywriter's experience, turn-around time, and market demand.

Rates for a copywriting job extremely vary — from 35 USD (as stated by Upwork) to over 100 USD per hour.

By understanding these typical rates, you ensure that the investment you are making in the copywriter is justified, and the value added to your business is tangible.

Setting a Budget for Hiring a Copywriter

Setting a budget for hiring a copywriter is about balancing cost against value. While cost plays a crucial role in crafting your budget, focusing solely on saving may mean sacrificing quality.

It might seem tempting to lower costs by hiring a less-expensive copywriter, but remember — good copywriting is an investment that drives business growth.

A smart budgeting strategy is about setting a price range that comfortably houses quality and affordability. Such a budget takes into account factors like the complexity of the work, the experience of the copywriter, and, of course, market rates.

If you're comfortable with being public about your budget, make it part of your job ad too, not to get candidates who are out of your budget range.

Once you have a clear budget in mind, you're another step closer to finding the ideal copywriter to boost your business.

Exploring the Best Platforms to Hire a Copywriter

After acknowledging your specific copywriting needs, introducing the platforms to hire competent copywriters becomes the logical next step. Be it freelance platforms, job boards, or copywriting agencies, each comes with its unique set of merits.

Aim to get tons of applicants — advertise widely:

  • Capture top freelance platforms such as Upwork, Fiverr, and Freelancer
  • Assimilate renowned job boards including Indeed, Glassdoor, and LinkedIn
  • Harness the full potential of copywriting agencies

Navigating freelance platforms: Upwork, Fiverr, and Freelancer

Freelance platforms harbor a multitude of talent, making for a versatile, one-stop-shop for your copywriting requirements.

  1. Upwork hosts a huge base of professionals, ensuring you find the perfect match for your project. They also offer easy collaboration tools to facilitate communication between you and the copywriter.

Screenshot 2024-08-04 at 15.42.36.png

  1. Fiverr, known for its gig-based structure, allows you to pinpoint professionals based on specific tasks, presenting clear cost structures and expectations upfront.

  2. Freelancer, with its contest feature, encourages copywriters to compete for your specific task. This encourages creativity while delivering affordable rates due to healthy competition.

Utilizing job boards: Indeed, Glassdoor, and LinkedIn

Job boards are a traditional yet potent route for efficient hiring.

  1. Indeed, with its thorough screening process, adds an extra layer of assurance on the quality of copywriters.

  2. Glassdoor offers you insights into the copywriter’s past engagements, leading to more informed decisions.

  3. LinkedIn enhances your ability to tap into a professional network for potential connections with seasoned copywriters.

Leveraging copywriting agencies

Agencies, with their specialized portfolios, streamline your recruitment process to secure experienced copywriters.

For example,

  1. Writing Studio offers custom writing solutions, providing a hassle-free option for businesses in need of specialized copywriting.

  2. Superside, with its highly skilled team of copywriters, affirms quality content deliverables for your business.

  3. iWriter offers swift and economical services for businesses requiring quick turnaround times.

Armed with this knowledge, securing your ideal copywriter becomes a straightforward process. The targeted talent hunt equips your organisation with the right language to connect with your audience, converting prospective clients into real-time business opportunities.

How to Evaluate a Copywriter's Portfolio

Key elements in a portfolio unveil the copywriter's capabilities. Its quality evaluation indicates the level of expertise the copywriter possesses. While relevance of past projects underlines the copywriter's ability to cater to your distinct needs.

Remember, you're looking for that one out of a hundred copywriter who will be a perfect fit for you. To do that, you will have to access their portfolio and ask to do a test writing task.

Identifying Key Elements in a Copywriter's Portfolio

A copywriter's portfolio serves as a window, revealing their capabilities and expertise. The first element to scrutinize is the diversity of the content.

A versatile copywriter often showcases a mix of topics, industries, and writing styles. Diversity indicates adaptability and the ability to generate fresh, engaging content across various domains.

To ensure the copywriter can create authoritative and informative pieces, peruse through their research-intensive samples.

A well-researched article or blog signifies an understanding of the topic and an ability to conduct comprehensive research.

Also, consider the call-to-action (CTA) elements in their portfolio. A good copywriter knows how to craft effective CTAs, subtly persuading readers to take a specific course of action, such as signing up for a newsletter or purchasing a product.

Assessing the Quality of a Copywriter's Work

Quality of the written content indicates copywriter's command over language and their ability to communicate effectively. It comprises clear, concise, and mistake-free writing which is crucial for creating engaging texts.

First, assess the structure and organization of the content. A well-structured piece of copy ensures easy readability, with a logical flow of ideas that keeps the reader's attention from start to finish.

Second, the language and grammar use gives you insight into the copywriter’s proficiency in the language.

The choice of words, tone, and language style all contribute to a copy's effectiveness and reader engagement.

Ultimately, carefully examine the originality of the content. Plagiarized or derivative content not only undermines credibility but can also lead to legal consequences.

Be aware, that sometimes portfolios are not the best indicator of a copywriter's talent. Oftentimes, these are editors who do the polishing and make a copywriter shine.

Employment of online detection tools like Copyscape can help confirm the content's originality. While Writitude will help with text analysis and determining the nuances of its style and tone.

Understanding the Relevance of a Copywriter's Past Projects to Your Needs

When assessing a copywriter's portfolio, you're not simply looking for a competent writer but a professional who can tailor their skills to your specific needs.

To determine this, thoroughly examine the copywriter's past projects and clientele.

Consider if the copywriter has experience in your industry. Industry familiarity can imply a nuanced understanding of your audience and the ability to craft relevant, effective copy.

Finally, consider samples that reflect the type of content you require. If you need product descriptions, focus on samples of descriptive content.

Looking for blog posts? Check out long-form articles in the portfolio. This will give you a palpable sense of whether the copywriter's past work aligns with your current requirements.

The more relevant the portfolio, the more likely the copywriter will be able to produce the work that matches your needs.

Conducting an Effective Interview with a Potential Copywriter

After initial screening of the applicants and revision of the test tasks you can ask to send along with their CVs, it's time to prepare for an interview.

First, see the applicants who answered all the points you asked to address in your job ad. Also, make sure their application was tailored and not generated with AI.

Preparing for the Interview: Questions to Ask

As a hiring manager or business owner, you already know that asking the right questions in an interview can make the difference between a great hire and a costly mistake.

But what specific questions should you ask when interviewing a copywriter?

First, delve into their experience. Behind each piece they've written lies a story -how they sourced information, met deadlines, and approached their craft.

A fundamental question would be "Can you walk me through your process when given a new project or topic to write about?"

Next, focus on their flexibility. "Can you give examples of how you've adapted your writing style to fit different brand voices or reach different audiences?"

This reveals their ability to shape-shift their writing tone and style — a crucial skill for a copywriter.

Thorough preparation for your interview can significantly improve your likelihood of finding a copywriter that meets your specific needs.

Assessing the Copywriter's Communication Skills and Understanding of Your Industry

How well does your prospective copywriter understand your business? Can they articulate complex ideas simply and clearly?

Assessing these things during the interview will help you determine if they’re a good fit for your company.

For example, ask about industry-specific articles they've written, which can help gauge their expertise and curiosity in your field. A question like "Are you familiar with industry jargon or terms used in our field?" shows whether they can write content that resonates with your audience.

Also, consider their communication skills. A copywriter should be, above all, a good listener. Ask them to summarize your company's offerings or your brand voice based on the conversation.

Their answer will demonstrate their listening skills and their ability to distil and communicate complex information.

Discussing the Copywriter's Work Process and Availability

Finally, understanding a potential copywriter’s workflow and capacity is fundamental. Questions such as "How do you manage your work, particularly when under pressure?" or "What's your response time when dealing with requests or feedback?" can highlight their organisational skills and dedication.

There’s reality in the adage ‘Time is money’, especially in the world of copywriting where content calendars are often packed and deadlines are tight. A copywriter who proves they can efficiently tackle tasks and meet deadlines is worth their weight in gold.

In conclusion, an effective interview demands preparation in formulating insightful questions and accurately assessing responses. Deeper than the words written, lies the person behind them.

This step ensures you hire a talented professional who aligns with your company goals and has the versatility to excel in every project.

Ordering a Paid Test Article

When you decide to order a paid test article from a copywriter, start by outlining your expectations clearly. Detail the topic, target audience, and any specific points you want covered.

This helps the copywriter understand the task and ensures they deliver content that meets your needs. Provide a word count and a deadline to keep the project on track. Clear communication from the beginning sets the stage for a successful collaboration.

After setting the parameters, review the copywriter's past work to gauge their style and skill. Look for samples that match the tone you seek. A paid test article not only evaluates the writer's skills but also tests how well they follow your guidelines.

This process helps you find a reliable copywriter who can consistently produce strong content for your projects.

Finalizing the Hiring Process: Setting Expectations and Onboarding

So you've conducted the interviews and found a potential copywriter — the one who can put your thoughts into persuasive words. The next crucial phase is to finalize the hiring process. Here's how you can do it.

Now it's time to sett defined expectations and deliverables.

Setting Clear Expectations and Deliverables

Having a clear understanding of what you want the copywriter to achieve for you is paramount for a productive working relationship.

Cover expectations around deadlines, communication preferences, and revision procedures, and you have a strong foundation for success.

Use tools like ProWritingAid, Acrolinx and Writitude to clearly define expectations around style and tone of voice of the texts for each audience type and channels.

Drafting a Contract: Key Elements to Include

The contract you draft with your copywriter is the safeguard for both parties. Ensuring it has all the critical aspects covered is important for a smooth working relationship.

It should clearly outline the scope of the project, including the specific tasks the copywriter will perform, deadlines for drafts and final versions, payment terms, confidentiality clauses, and terms of termination.

Furthermore, intellectual property rights are a critical piece of any creative contract. These define who owns the created content and how and where it can be used.

Having a thorough and comprehensive contract places everyone on the same page from the get-go, minimizing potential misunderstandings or conflicts as the project progresses.

Onboarding a Copywriter

Regular communication proves being extremely beneficial in fine-tuning the content strategy. Remember, your copywriter is not a mind reader; the responsibility of clear briefing often lies with you.

Consider using an online platform, like Workelo, for onboarding your writers in a structured and documented way.

Screenshot 2024-08-04 at 16.54.09.png

Discussing a brief or a request for content further, understanding the writer's maximum capacity per month — all these processes are key to your successful collaboration in the following months.

If you are an agency, hire more people than you need. In this way, you will be able to compare their work, as well as make sure you have enough capacity to match and support your growth.

Establishing Effective Communication Channels

Copywriters do not operate in a vacuum. They often rely on your team's or customer's input to tailor messages that bring value, resonate with your brand voice and targeted audience.

By maintaining regular communication and really investing time into editing and feedback, you gather their queries, provide them with necessary details, and make timely decisions.

This fuels your copywriter with the necessary elements to deliver precise content that aligns perfectly with your brand identity and business goals. This helps them improve quickly.

Providing Constructive Feedback

Feedback is a catalyst for growth rather than merely a critique tool. But for it to be effective, the right delivery method must be employed.

When delivering feedback to your copywriter, it should be geared towards promoting improvement, and not breeding resentments.

To provide constructive feedback, start with acknowledging the positives — what the copywriter did well. Then, address the areas of improvements by suggesting alternative methods or ideas.

This method ensures that the feedback process becomes a collaborative effort aimed at refining, not only the copywriter’s skills, but the overall quality of work produced for your business.

Decades of psychological research highlight the importance of using positive reinforcement in facilitating behavior or performance improvements.

By exercising this in your feedback process, you stimulate creativity, improve job satisfaction, and encourage a proactive attitude towards work in your copywriter.

Constructive feedback is not a one-off event. It’s a continuous process that seeks to reinforce good behaviors and correct unfavorable ones over time.

Developing a systematic procedure for giving constructive feedback can significantly boost your copywriter’s productivity and passion.

Recognizing and Rewarding Good Work

Recognition for a job well done can significantly improve your copywriter's productivity, creativity, and dedication. Everyone thrives on positive affirmation. When a copywriter does an exceptional job, make sure to highlight their success.

Providing rewards and incentives for good performance could range from public recognition, offering tangible rewards, or providing opportunities for growth and development.

Not only does this improve the relationship between you and the copywriter, but it also embeds an atmosphere of continuous improvement in your working relationship.

A growing body of research supports the positive correlation between employee recognition and work motivation. In fact, about 69% of employees admitted they would work harder if they felt their efforts were better recognized.

In summary, rewarding and recognizing your copywriter's good work cultivates loyalty, boosts job satisfaction, and promotes a culture of excellence.

Ultimately, these practices yield consistency in delivering high-quality work that resonates with your business and target audience.

Don't Just Find a Copywriter, Acquire the Right Talent

Over the course of this guide, we unearthed the importance of understanding your needs, leveraging professional networks, vetting potential copywriters' portfolios and testing their skills. Simultaneously, no understating the impact of culture fit and trial projects.

The right copywriter can truly level up your content game, so don't put off the process any longer. Would you consider letting a copywriter take a stab at one of your ongoing projects as a paid trial task?

Let your next step be a stride towards quality content, and remember, the right words can turn your small business into a big brand. It's not only about finding a copywriter, it's about discovering the voice of your brand.

--> There is no consistency without automation. You can start defining your band's tone of voice and ensuring your content consistency now with Writitude — register your free account here.